The Limits to American Power

James Adler

When it comes to issues of genuine international concern, such as  Iran's deeply offensive current President, in tandem with its nuclear program,  sometimes I find myself wishing that America's neoconservatives were right about the magnitude of American power; but these neoconservative strategists would be wise not to forget even a sampling of modern history's salient and humbling facts.

The United States:
  • was not able to stop either the Soviet Union or China from acquiring nuclear weapons.
  • could not prevent the USSR's post-War  takeover and occupation of Eastern Europe
  • could not stop China from becoming Communist in 1949.
  • could not make North Korea to surrender in the Korean War (even with 50,000 US soldiers dead).
  • actually lost the Vietnam war to tiny North Vietnam (with another 50,000 US soldiers dead).
  • could not prevent Cuba from becoming Communist in 1959 or the Bay of Pigs from floundering in 1961.
  • could not prevent the crushing of the Hungarian revolution of 1956 or Dubcek's Czech "Spring" of 1968.
  • could not rescue the American hostages in the US Embassy in Iran.
  • could not prevent India or Pakistan from acquiring nuclear weapons.
  • could not create a successful world order of peace and prosperity after the implosion of Soviet and East European Communism in 1989.
  • could not catch either Osama bin Laden or Taliban leader Mullah Mohammad Omar or will even necessarily prevent the Taliban from retaking Afghanistan.
  • could not remotely succeed in Iraq, and for that matter could not prevent Israel from claiming Jerusalem as its capital and pouring 450,000 of its settlers over the Green Line--both of these also against American wishes and policies.

There are limits to American power.

Sometimes I also wish there weren't such limits, and neoconservatives may laugh now, but consider the low likelihood of US success at destroying a multiplicity of secret, dispersed, buried, and bunkered Iranian nuclear sites, and the impact - on the United States, Europe, the Arab and Islamic worlds, and moderate Muslim societies like those of Jordan and Egypt and Pakistan - of pictures of the scores of inevitably mutilated and burnt bodies of Iranian children getting continuously rebroadcast on Al Jazeera and the rest of worldwide television.



Comment on this Article:
Please enter your comment below and then click the "submit" button. Your name and contact information is requested. We will publish your name and city, but will only publish your contact information by your request.











Return to the Table of Contents




Articles may be quoted or republished in full with attribution
to the author and harvardsquarecommentary.org.



This site is designed and managed by Neil Turner at Neil Turner Concepts


H
S
C